When photographs of Israelis abducted during the Hamas-led October 7, 2023, attack appeared on the streets of New York, they soon became the center of a heated public controversy. As some New Yorkers put up posters to raise awareness of the hostages, others began tearing them down, sparking confrontations that exposed deep political and social divisions. For Israeli-American filmmaker Nimrod (Nim) Shapira, a graduate of Tel Aviv University’s Steve Tisch School of Film and Television who has called New York home since 2013, the controversy was both personal and impossible to ignore.