Waterline Eyeliner 101: How to Put Eyeliner on Your Waterline + Make It Stay Waterline eyeliner is one of the fastest ways to make your eyes stand out, whether you want subtle definition or a dramatic statement. Applying eyeliner to your waterline takes a little practice, and the payoff shows up in every photo. The waterline is a sensitive area, so getting liner to last and stay comfortable comes down to three things: the right technique, the right formula and knowing how to tightline the upper rim.