September romance shows might not be as steamy as this summer’s romance shows (and I do mean that literally, considering we’re swapping beach days for cozy movie nights and warm drinks ). If there’s anything that makes me want to watch a new romance show, it’s cuddling up with my favorite treats and a blanket, so naturally I scoured the internet for the best romance shows premiering this month. Here are the 5 best new romance shows you can watch in September 2026 — including some premiering this week!